First off, OMG THE TITLE RHYMES. That shouldn’t make me nearly this happy, but it does. As always, full spoilers of this episode to follow.
I think this might be the most fucked up episode yet, full of torture, amputation and scary shadow demons, and I loved it. We’re introduced to a bunch of new characters, along with two new key locations, and we’re treated to plenty of great dialogue as the plot advances.
I loved the opening of this episode. It was a stark (sorry) reminder that not all Lannister soldiers are evil, as the previous episode would have us believe. It was nice to see two men at arms having a conversation that I’m sure many fans have had- who would win in a fight between x and y? I was intrigued to see that rumours of Renly’s bed time preferences have spread as far as the lowly foot soldiers. Sadly, such merriment was short lived, as Grey Wind arrived to turn the poor soldiers inside out.
Immediately after this we meet Roose Bolton. Whilst he wasn’t as creepy as I’d imagined him, Roose was perfectly calm and seemingly normal, until he started talking about flaying Lannister officers. He’s definitely someone that new viewers will be keeping an eye on. Next, we meet Oona Chaplin’s character, who was reported to be named Jeyne, but gives the name Alyssa, or maybe it was Talissa, I don’t know, it was hard to hear. If she is indeed Jeyne Westerling, as was indicated when she was cast, I’m really interested in how HBO are going to change Robb’s romance on screen. It seems to me like he’s going to fall for this strong willed foreigner, only to find that she is in fact the daughter of one of his enemies’ vassals. I honestly think that would be more compelling than what happens ‘off-screen’ in the books, where Jeyne nurses Robb, they have sex, and he marries her out of honour.
Down south in King’s Landing we learn that, yep, Joffrey’s still a raging arsehole, and so are his cronies, Ser Lancel and Ser Meryn. It was nice to see a brief glimpse of the Hound’s look of distaste as Joffrey ordered Sansa’s beating. Luckily, Tyrion arrives before any real damage is done. It was refreshing to see someone teaching Joffrey a lesson, even if it’s bound to come back and bite Tyrion in the arse. This episode reinforced my love for Bronn. I reckon he could easily take Ser Meryn, he spends his days beating up teenage girls. Jerome Flynn gets to deliver what is easily the best line of the entire show: “There’s no cure for being a cunt.” How right you are, Bronn.
Speaking of Joffrey fighting back against Tyrion, he really shows his most sadistic side when he decides to send a message to his uncle. I’m concerned about the show’s treatment of King Joff, as I’ve previously mentioned. We know that Joffrey’s a cunt. They’ve shown that plenty of times. In the novels Joffrey is arrogant and petulant, and somewhat twisted, but he’s not yet a full blown psychopath. I’m worried that the show is making him into an evil caricaturefor the sake of having a clear villain on the show, which is otherwise populated with ambiguous, well rounded characters.
Later on we get to see Tyrion does what he does best, which is schooling some arrogant fool in how the game of thrones is played. Lancel goes from an arrogant, haughty knight to a snivelling child in about 10 seconds, and Tyrion gains another informant. As he keeps saying, Tyrion is not Ned Stark, and he intends to keep all of his extremities attached to his body.
Arya and Gendry continue to have the most compelling plot, going from peril to peril. Now they’re imprisoned in the ruins of Harrenhal, which looks appropriately huge and terrifying. The scenes of torture make you really worry about the fate of these two beloved characters in a show where plot armour is often shown to be asreliable as a shield made of rice pudding. We get to see Arya’s first nightly revenge-prayer, which is something I think that non-book readers will latch onto and really enjoy, especially as her kill list continues to grow.
The Tickler was, I thought, superbly played. I don’t know the name of the actor they cast, but he’s perfect. He just seems so calm and casual when he’s torturing these innocent people in a pretty horrific (and creative) way. I noticed that the Mountain was re cast, which seemed pointless to me, though I suppose it must have been down to some scheduling conflict. Thankfully, Lord Tywin arrives just in time (the Lannister men seem to be doing a lot of that this week), and proves that although he can be cold and calculating, he is not a cruel man. He insists that the prisoners be put to work, saving Gendry and Arya, and points out that Arya is, in fact, a girl. I’m looking forward to seeing their scenes together, as Tywin actually came across as quite likable when he was speaking to Arya. Who knows, maybe we’ll see a softer side of the old lion.
In Renly’s camp, Littlefinger is up to his usual tricks, trying to act innocent in order to build himself an insurance policy, should the Lannister’s fall. His scene with Catelyn was stunning, and seeing the way that the sight of Cat going from fierce and angry to almost broken with grief was really emotional. I can’t believe that so many GoT fans were outraged by Michelle Fairley being cast as Cat. She stole the show this week, and the music in this scene was incredible. We then see what passes for negotiations between Renly and Stannis, and it really hammers home just how different these two brothers are. I found myself unable to root for either one of them, as they both have their flaws. I reckon GRRM will surprise everyone and put Gendry on the Iron Throne, when all’s done.
Daenerys finally gets somewhere! She manages to gain access to Qarth, despite acting like a true Targaryen, i.e. mental, arrogant and angry. This scene was a stark reminder that even Dany is susceptible to the Targaryen crazy gene. Xaro came across as very imposing, yet charming, and I think seeing him try to romance the Khaleesi will be interesting. Also, I think I spotted Pryat Pree amongst the Thirteen, and damn that guy looks creepy.
Despite Catelyn stealing the show this week, I think it’s the final scene that will get everyone’s tongues a-wagging. We finally hear some of Davos’ history with Stannis, explaining why he is so fiercely loyal to his king, and the his king orders him to do something he is clearly not comfortable with. Stannis’ strong sense of honour clearly doesn’t prohibit him from using dark magic to assassinate his only brother!
We learn that Melisandre’s views on good and evil are different from Stannis’, and she comes across as being very otherworldly in this scene. I thought the shadow demon baby looked incredible, and I’m glad that the showrunners decided to really go for it in this bizare, fantasy heavy scene, rather than tone things down. Also, even as a veteran reader of the books I still don’t have a handle on Melisandre. She’s demonstrated time and time again that her god, R’hllor, has legitimate power, but we still don’t know for sure who she serves. Her ability to birth a demon on short notice seems to indicate that she’s not necessarily a force for good.
Either way, this episode’s closing scene reminds us that, although it has been forgotten, magic does still exist in Westeros. Dragons, Others, and now a shadow demon. The night is dark and full of terrors.